Searching for the broken-down chiptune player of my dreams
This is a story from the old days before we had YouTube or the bandwidth to stream audio.
Back then, if you wanted to listen to music from a video game, _maybe_ you could track down an official soundtrack CDâor, if you were a mega nerd like me, youâd download ripped chiptunes and their special players. These files are basically cut-down versions of the original game data, containing the gameâs music data and its original player; itâs intended to be paired with a special audio player which is essentially a cut-down emulator for the console which emulates the CPU and sound chip but not the rest of the hardware. Since they stripped out anything the game didnât need to play the music, they were usually tiny. Entire soundtracks for 8-bit and 16-bit games could easily fit in under 50KB1, which made it easy for me to sample stuff on a whim even with a dialup internet connection.
For me, these were a great way to try out the music to games Iâd read about but never actually played. It was _especially_ great for those legendary games Iâd heard about that used weird hardware and that Iâd never have gotten to try on their original systems. Thereâs one game in particular that fascinated me: Konamiâs Lagrange Point. It was one of a set of NES games that were famous in the early emulation scene for using the âexpansion audioâ feature of the Famicom, the Japanese version of the system. This allowed game cartridges to include extra audio hardware which games could use simultaneously with the builtin chip for richer and much more complex music. This feature was missing from international versions of the NES, and until emulation most people outside Japan had only heard rumours about what games like _Castlevania III_ had actually sounded like in their original versions.
_Lagrange Point_ had an especially mystical reputation for being the only NES game using Konamiâs VRC7 sound chip2, which was much more advanced than anything else on the system. It used a sound chip using entirely different technology from every other NES game; its Yamaha YM2413 is an FM synthesis chip closer to the 16-bit Sega Genesis than anything that anything else used on the NES3, and I just had to hear what that sounded like for myself. Here, click play and take a listen to the first track for yourself:
Itâs a nice sound, isnât it? Itâs surreal to me hearing sound like this coming out of an NES game that feels like it should have much more primitive instruments.
That said, when I grabbed an .NSF rip of the game and popped it in the first player I could find that did VRC7 audio, thatâs not what I heard. What I heard was this:
Thatâs not really the same at all, is it? Those sound like different instruments entirely, something closer to a ânormalâ NES instrument sound than the warm smooth instruments the game is meant to use. That scratchiness in particular has always stuck with me; it gives the game a very distinctive broken-down sound with a texture completely unlike the original gameâs sound at all. Maybe this is the nostalgia talking, but I liked the sound at the time and I like it now. No one meant for it to sound this way, but I enjoy it all the same.
Fast forward about 25 years. I still use these custom players and ripped game audio today and happened to dig out the _Lagrange Point_ NSF. It didnât sound anything like the incorrect version Iâd imprinted on, so I thought Iâd hunt down that old player and take a listen again just to see if it was like I remembered. There was just one problem:
_Iâd forgotten what player it was._
I wasnât going to be able to listen to the broken-down chiptunes of my dreams if I didnât have the right player! Thus started my desperate hunt to see if I could figure out what it was.
I had the vague memory that it was a player called Meridian Advance, which was released back in 2001, but it definitely wasnât that. It doesnât have VRC7 support at all, so trying to play it back just got me silence and the very occasional sound it was playing from the regular NES sound chip.
If my one memory was out, what _was_ it? I started digging through every NSF player I could find from the late 90s through the early 00s, hoping _one_ of them would be the right one. BNSF? No VRC7 support at all. NEZplug? Plays normally. NSFten for Winamp? No VRC7. NotSo Fatso? Plays normally. Bleep? NESamp? Nosefart4? G-NSF? SlickNSF? MSP? Meridian Prime? No, no, no, no, no, no, and no. Itâs a hell of a list, and as I kept failing to find what I was looking for I started to wonder if Iâd imagined the whole thing.
Finally, I thought of something I should probably have considered in the first place. âMeridian Advanceâ implies itâs the _second_ Meridian, doesnât it? Just like the Game Boy Advance? Well, yes: Meridian Advance was the second of three Meridian sound players which started development after the developer lost the source code to the original Meridian in a hard drive crash5. I naively assumed that Meridian Advance could do everything the original could do, but that was a bad assumption. The original Meridian from 2000 really _did_ have VRC7 support, and it was _exactly_ the broken sound I remembered. Here it is:
(Yes, cloning Winamp was the most actual thing an audio player could do back then.) It runs fine under Wine so I gave it a shot and it really does sound _exactly_ like I remember it.
Want to hear it yourself? You can download Meridian right here, and the Lagrange Point NSF here; should work fine on modern Windows or under Wine for Mac/Linux.
1. Thatâs about half a second of streaming audio on YouTube. ↩
2. Yes, yes, I know, that _Tiny Toon_ game uses it too. But it doesnât use it for _sound_ now does it? ↩
3. To be exact, this is the same chip used in the Japanese Sega Master System and the MSX-Music, so it certainly had a history of being used on 8-bit systems. Outside Japan though, this sound is associated with systems much more advanced than the NES. ↩
4. Yes, really. ↩
5. Closed source was the default for this stuff back then! This was a pretty common death state for this kind of app. ↩