PBS's 'Crime and Punishment' Doc Takes Bleeding-Heart Liberal Path Through History
“Crime and Punishment in America,” the four-part PBS series spanning the history of crime and punishment from America’s founding to the present day, features as executive producers liberal PBS omnipresence Ken Burns and doctumentary producer/director Sam Pollard, who “has edited several Spike Lee films, including Mo’ Better Blues, Jungle Fever, Clockers, and Bamboozled.” He was also a producer on Spike Lee's 2006 conspiracy-theory series on Hurricane Katrina. That combined work history hints of the tone, with a racism theme and other large social issues perched under the misleading title. Crime…was written and directed by Lynn Novick, who appeared on the PBS News Hour November 16 to hand-wring about “overincarceration,” narrated by actor Keith David (The Thing). Among the many talking heads was senior historian advisor Heather Ann Thompson, who also hammered on racial themes in her book on “Subway Vigilante” Bernard Goetz.The seven-plus hour runtime was replete with the usual hoary left-wing lines, delivered without context.Keith David: ….By the dawn of the 21st century, with less than 5% of the world's population, the United States would account for more than 20% of the incarcerated people on Earth.....Yale law professor James Forman Jr.: “When I think about crime and punishment in America, I think that it says that we are a very unforgiving country…. Slavery taught us and it taught the nation to think about black people as scary. It taught the nation to think of black people as dangerous, as lawbreaking. Well, if a country teaches itself for hundreds of years that black people are dangerous, that black people are criminal, that black people are scary, that black people don't feel pain, that black people don't care about their children, those beliefs aren't going to go away quickly.”Rafael Mangual is a right-of-center voice from the Manhattan Institute whose father was a NYPD detective, but overall the series was suffused with bleeding-heart liberalism.David: ….a new generation of reformers would expose the cruelty, corruption, and prejudice that could be found in every part of the criminal justice system.The documentary covered a lot of historical ground, from the eugenics movement, to black anti-lynching activist Ida B. Wells, the force-feeding of the Suffragettes in prison, the Palmer Raids, the displacement of American Indian tribes, one of whom provided an anti-capitalist quote from a written archive: “The greatest object of their lives seems to be acquiring possessions, to be rich.”As NewsBusters previously noted, this ostensible “crime and punishment” documentary reached into the social issues of the day, including post-World War II abortion restrictions, historian Thompson lamenting, “…it turns out that the criminal justice system is not just about public safety. It is, in fact, as much about things like regulating morals, regulating the status quo.”In episode 4, poet Reginald Dwayne Betts, former prisoner who earned a Yale law degree and (naturally) a Macarthur fellowship, author of Bastards of the Reagan Era, sounded like a leftist caricature: “What does it mean to live in a country that would only view prison as the most violent and dangerous place in the world...And never think about the richness of humanity of the people who live there and never think about the ways in which those folks are sort of fighting on a regular basis against the desperation, against the depravity in a world that's said that they have no principles?”Narrator David repeated the still-unexplained statistic: “….under Republicans and Democrats, Americans everywhere got tough on crime, built more prisons, and locked more people away in them. By 2008, the United States -- with less than 5% of the world's population-- would account for more than 20% of the incarcerated people on Earth.”Washington Post columnist George Will faulted how the series “meanders to tangential topics” and its reliance on “Larry Krasner, Philadelphia’s impeccably progressive district attorney….In his enthusiasm for what progressive-speak calls ‘decarcerating,’ he says ‘there are deep evils to having excessive supervision’ of imprisoned felons.”Willie Horton made an appearance, letting law professor Forman reduced the issue of Massachusetts Gov. Michael Dukakis’s astonishingly lenient parole system for murderers, into racism.PBS's "Crime and Punishment" series with Yale law prof. James Forman whining "[the Willie Horton ad] sent the message that if you exercised any amount of discretion in favor of basic humanity" for a black prisoner who then committed a crime, you'd be remembered for that alone. https://t.co/ZqiK8A7kEd— Clay Waters 🇮🇱 (@claywaters44) November 21, 2026Forman Jr.: ….It sent the message that if you exercised any amount of discretion in favor of basic humanity towards somebody who is incarcerated-- giving them the right to parole or giving them the right to a day pass, to go to work, if you did anything like that and a crime was committed and it was a black person who did it, nothing else that you said or did would be remembered by the populace.The series’ conclusion, delivered by poet Betts, underlined the unsubtle theme of the series: “…we all deserve a world that is governed by mercy and not one that's governed by vengeance.”Columnist George Will correctly concluded that the series “includes too much ideological ax-grinding, and too few contributions from people who have thought deeply about these subjects.”