No. 72
Your edition of Inland Empire Law Weekly has arrived. We've got some crime news and more explainers of the propositions on your ballot. If you haven't read all of our election coverage yet, you can find our coverage of the race between Andrea Garcia and Michelle Paradise here, and our coverage of other issues on your ballot here. I especially recommend sharing last week's explainer: Why are all of those justices on your ballot? (The answer in short: Californians in 1934 wanted to depoliticize the judiciary.)
We also have a recap of the simmering tension between the liberal minority and conservative majority of the Supreme Court—in 1984. On this date that year, Justice William Rehnquist defended the court against accusations of judicial impropriety brought by its three-person minority. That's at the bottom of the edition.
## Table of Contents
* Election
* Prop 1: There’s a $11.25 billion housing bond on the ballot this November
* Prop 4: Should California taxpayers chip in to fund political campaigns?
* Prop. 43 would make special taxes harder to pass. That’s the point, say anti-tax advocates
* Prop 45: CEQA overhaul could shift who holds power over building
* Crime
* Man to stand trial for death of woman killed during fight with deputy
* Testimony to begin Monday for man accused of 2003 murder in National Forest
* Hearing postponed for felon who repeatedly sexually abused Riverside girl
* Cathedral City man who fatally shot buddy convicted of murder
* Parolee accused of gunning down Temecula woman arraigned
* MoVal trio charged with perpetrating estate fraud, stealing funds
* Parolee who shot man 12 times in street confrontation convicted of murder
* Charges dismissed against man formerly accused of causing drug death
* Get involved
* Become an advocate for children in need
* Free legal aid clinics
* Local calendar
* State news
* Trump sues California over allegations of noncitizens registering to vote
* ICE arrests alarm California’s community colleges. How much can campus officials do?
* California falls short on Medi-Cal fraud, state report says
* California sues to stop National Archives closure that tribes say came without warning
* National news
* Trump administration appeals judge's order blocking White House ban of 3 news outlets
* Other sources
* Today in history: Rehnquist's court packing speech
* Book recommendation
## Election
* * *
### Prop 1: There’s a $11.25 billion housing bond on the ballot this November
For years, California has grappled with a problem that has affected nearly every aspect of our society: The state doesn’t have enough homes that people can afford to live in. Proposition 1 aims to address that crisis.
It’s estimated that more than 180,000 Californians are homeless. Rents are so high that a minimum wage worker would need to work 102 hours a week to afford a typical one-bedroom apartment, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition.
A big piece of that problem is construction: Not enough homes are being built. Fewer than a third of California cities and counties are on track to permit enough market-rate housing to hit their state-mandated targets, and fewer than 6% are on track for very low-income housing. Those targets are based on the state’s assumption that we need nearly 2.5 million more homes.
If it passes, Prop. 1 would allow the state to sell $11.25 billion in general obligation bonds to fund various types of housing, including homes for veterans, homeless Californians, renters, homeowners, farmworkers, students and tribes.
Prop. 1 would fund a variety of programs.
Here’s how it breaks down:
* * *
### Prop 4: Should California taxpayers chip in to fund political campaigns?
In 1988, a Democrat, a Republican and an independent in the state Legislature co-authored a ballot measure to ban most political campaigns from using public money.
Their rationale? There was already too much money in politics.
“It certainly makes no sense to open the biggest money source of all, the taxpayers’ purses and wallets,” proponents argued. Nearly 60% of voters agreed.
Almost four decades later, some good-government groups argue that the state needs to do the _exact opposite_ to counter the influence of money in politics.
They, along with the state Democratic Party, are backing Proposition 4 on the November ballot, which would lift the 1988 ban and authorize the state and most local governments to set up public campaign financing systems for state and local races.
Seven charter cities in California already have public campaign financing...
* * *
### Prop. 43 would make special taxes harder to pass. That’s the point, say anti-tax advocates
In 2022, 58% of Los Angeles city voters approved a hefty tax on mansion sales.
In 2024, 62% of Sonoma County voters backed a half-cent sales tax to fund wildfire response and other emergency services.
Neither would have become law under the threshold set by Proposition 43, which would require a two-thirds vote to pass any local tax measures that pay for specific services.
Anti-tax advocates such as the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, which helped get Prop. 43 on the ballot, say it should be harder to tax Californians in a state where tax rates are already high.
Californians voted in 1996 to establish a two-thirds threshold for special tax measures...
* * *
### Prop 45: CEQA overhaul could shift who holds power over building
Cars drive along Highway 101 through Richardson Grove State Park in Humboldt County on Aug. 22, 2027. Photo by Brian Baer, California State Parks
In 2014, residents and environmental groups argued in a lawsuit that a California Department of Transportation road project planned to run through Richardson Grove State Park failed to properly evaluate how it could harm the redwood trees. It still took courts a total of 15 years to resolve all of the related legal complaints before Caltrans could move forward with building.
Environmental advocates say the litigation led to changes that better protect redwood trees. But pro-building advocates point to the case as evidence that the California Environmental Quality Act and the review process it requires need an overhaul.
Proposition 45 , a November ballot initiative that aims to streamline the process, would change how fights like this one play out.
At the heart of the debate over the measure is who holds power over environmental reviews...
* * *
## Crime
* * *
### Man to stand trial for death of woman killed during fight with deputy
RIVERSIDE (CNS) - A San Diego County man accused of assaulting a sheriff's deputy and trying to grab the lawman's gun during a confrontation in Corona, culminating in the defendant's girlfriend being fatally shot, must stand trial for murder, a judge ruled Friday.
Eric John Nourani, 35, was arrested in 2024 after the shooting that took the life of 30-year-old Jennifer Rose Dobbins of Imperial Beach.
Riverside Superior Judge Mary Fuller found...
* * *
### Testimony to begin Monday for man accused of 2003 murder in National Forest
BANNING (CNS) - Prosecution testimony is slated to get underway Monday in the trial of a 44-year-old man accused of gunning down a one-time friend over money more than 20 years ago in the San Bernardino National Forest.
James Robert Landi of San Mateo was arrested last December following an extensive investigation by the Riverside County Sheriff's Department's Cold Case Unit.
Landi is charged with first-degree murder, a special circumstance allegation of lying in wait and sentence-enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations for the death of 18-year-old Reynaldo Nino Burts in October 2003.
Riverside Superior Judge Mark Singerton...
* * *
### Hearing postponed for felon who repeatedly sexually abused Riverside girl
RIVERSIDE (CNS) - At the request of the defense, sentencing was postponed Friday for a probationer who sexually assaulted a 12-year-old Riverside girl over a months-long period.
Last month, a Riverside jury convicted Robert Downing Scott Jr., 34, of Riverside, of seven counts of lewd acts on a child, five counts of aggravated sexual assault of a minor, two counts each of contacting a minor to commit a felony and possession of child pornography, and one count of using a minor to produce child porn.
Scott was slated for sentencing Friday morning, but his attorney requested a deferral to December for unspecified reasons
Prosecutors say the victim encounted the defendant online on the site "Spotafriend."
* * *
### Cathedral City man who fatally shot buddy convicted of murder
RIVERSIDE (CNS) - A 22-year-old man who fatally shot his lifelong friend during an act of gunplay in Sky Valley was convicted Friday of second- degree murder.
A Riverside jury deliberated about four days before finding Alexis Yahir Duran of Cathedral City guilty of second-degree murder for the 2023 death of 17-year-old Adam Pineda of Desert Hot Springs.
Jurors returned the verdict Friday morning. Although they convicted him of murder, the panel did not find him guilty of sentence-enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations, which would have doubled his sentence.
Prosecutors say Duran and Pineda had been best friends since elementary school...
* * *
### Parolee accused of gunning down Temecula woman arraigned
MURRIETA (CNS) - A parolee accused of gunning down a 30-year-old Temecula woman only days after he was let out of state prison pleaded not guilty Friday to first-degree murder and other charges.
Rashad Kysim Populus, 28, of Los Angeles, was arrested last week following a Riverside County Sheriff's Department investigation into the slaying of Shaquilah Kaprise Howard.
Along with murder, Populus is charged with being a felon in possession of a firearm and sentence-enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations, as well as parole violations.
The defendant was arraigned Friday before Superior Court Judge Judith Clark, who scheduled a felony settlement conference for Dec. 1 at the Southwest Justice Center in Murrieta.
According to sheriff's Sgt. Carlos Mendoza...
* * *
### MoVal trio charged with perpetrating estate fraud, stealing funds
RIVERSIDE (CNS) - Three Moreno Valley residents accused of ripping off seniors in an estate fraud scheme, stealing thousands of dollars, were charged Thursday with forgery, grand theft and multiple other offenses.
Darnell Thompson, 73, Danielle Thompson, 22, and Nakethia Jacquin Taylor, 53, were arrested earlier this week following a Riverside County Sheriff's Department investigation that began almost two years ago.
Darnell Thompson is charged with nearly two dozen felony counts, including attempted murder, conspiracy, forgery, grand theft, money laundering, as well as a sentence-enhancing white-collar crime allegation.
Thompson pleaded not guilty during a solo arraignment Thursday before Superior Court Judge Gary Polk, who scheduled a felony settlement conference for Oct. 26 at the Riverside Hall of Justice.
His two co-defendants, Danielle Thompson and Taylor, both posted bonds...
* * *
### Parolee who shot man 12 times in street confrontation convicted of murder
INDIO (CNS) - A parolee who gunned down a man more than a decade ago for crashing into his SUV on an Indio street was convicted Tuesday of first- degree murder and other offenses.
An Indio jury deliberated less than a day before finding James "Chip" Milton Nathaniel, 39, of Beaumont, guilty of the 2015 slaying of 35- year-old Apolonio Carranza.
Along with murder, the jury convicted Nathaniel of being a felon in possession of a firearm, witness intimidation, spousal abuse and sentence- enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations.
Riverside Superior Judge Otis Sterling scheduled a...
* * *
### Charges dismissed against man formerly accused of causing drug death
NDIO (CNS) - Charges were dismissed Tuesday against a 56-year-old man previously accused of providing a fatal dose of methamphetamine to an acquaintance, following a judge's ruling there was insufficient evidence to bound the defendant over for trial.
William Joseph Leonard of Palm Desert was charged last year with involuntary manslaughter and possession of controlled substances for sale following a Cathedral City Police Department investigation into the death of 56- year-old Ricky Heath.
At the end of a preliminary hearing Tuesday, Riverside County Superior Court Judge Michael Dest at the Larson Justice Center in Indio dismissed both felony counts, finding no grounds for trying Leonard.
According to police, on the night of Jan. 18, 2025, fire department paramedics went to...
* * *
## Get involved
### Become an advocate for children in need
San Bernardino needs more volunteer Court Appointed Special Advocates. CASA volunteers are special advocates who advocate for children that have entered the juvenile dependency court system. These children need someone to look out for them, and that someone can be you. CASA volunteers attend court and review records, but they do not have to be attorneys. The time commitment is 10-15 hours per month. Read more at the program's website.
For Children in Foster Care, CASA Volunteers Help Make Summer Feel Like ChildhoodWith nearly 6,000 kids expected in foster care this year, the nonprofit Voices for Children says summer is when kids need CASA volunteers most.The Raincross GazetteMicaela Ricaforte
### Free legal aid clinics
Inland Empire Latino Lawyers Association hosts free legal aid clinics at 838 Alta St., Redlands, on the last Wednesday of every month. They also host clinics the first, second and fourth Monday of every month at Bordwell Park, 2008 Martin Luther King Blvd., Riverside. All clinics are held from 9 a.m.-1 p.m. More information at their website.
## Local calendar
* * *
## State news
* * *
### Trump sues California over allegations of noncitizens registering to vote
The Trump administration on Thursday sued California and Los Angeles County to try to force elections officials not to count potentially 20,000 registered voters’ ballots, in an extraordinary intervention 19 days before a consequential national election.
Federal prosecutors from the U.S. Justice Department this week wrote to California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and LA County Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan demanding that they verify the citizenship status of a specific list of registered voters, or set aside their ballots without counting them in November.
It’s part of a national push by the Trump administration to find instances of non-U.S. citizens voting illegally in elections. The Department of Homeland Security recently claimed that Nevada had nearly 16,000 non-citizens on its voter rolls; they sent the state the names of only 185 voters, who Nevada officials confirmed were all U.S. citizens.
California sends all registered voters a ballot in the mail...
* * *
### ICE arrests alarm California’s community colleges. How much can campus officials do?
A sign prohibiting immigration enforcement is displayed at San Diego City College in downtown San Diego on Oct. 9, 2026. Photo by Adriana Heldiz, CalMatters
Immigration enforcement agents are inciting panic at California’s community colleges.
Santa Monica College said that one of its students was arrested and deported last May. Then in December, Santa Barbara City College said that federal immigration officers used their campus parking lot as a staging ground, prompting an uproar from community activists.
Last month, the San Diego Community College District said ICE agents arrested a student on a public street that cuts through the urban campus and proceeded to chase another student up the steps of the school’s Arts and Humanities building.
Last Monday, federal agents arrested the father of a student in a campus parking lot at Allan Hancock College in Santa Maria, south of San Luis Obispo.
College presidents say they’re doing everything in their power to keep students safe and prevent federal immigration enforcement officers from coming on campus. But they admit that they have limited power in these situations.
State laws require colleges to notify students if...
* * *
### California falls short on Medi-Cal fraud, state report says
_This story was originally written by Jocelyn Wiener and published by_ CalMatters_._ Sign up_for their newsletters._
Is California doing enough to curtail Medi-Cal fraud?
The state auditor doesn’t think so.
A report released Thursday by Grant Parks, the state auditor, suggests the Department of Health Care Services is ill-equipped to stop pervasive abuse in Medi-Cal, a program that serves about 14 million Californians and pays out $200 billion annually.
The report described a “history of concern” about the department’s oversight of Medi‑Cal providers and classified it as “high-risk” for fraud, waste and abuse. The Department was first given the designation in 2007 for other reasons, including concerns about organizational restructuring and policymakers’ calls for increased accountability and program effectiveness.
In its response, the department disagreed with the auditor’s findings, saying the report “omits critical information and context, resulting in an incomplete analysis” and that it highlights “isolated anecdotes while ignoring system-wide data showing effective systems and controls.”
The report listed several concerning examples:
* Two medical providers billed almost $1.6 million in Medi-Cal services in 2024-25, despite having been deemed ineligible to participate in the program several years earlier.
* One transportation provider claimed to have driven 35 people in a single day, nine of them traveling more than 340 miles apiece. If this info was legitimate, the report said, the transportation provider would have traveled more than 3,000 miles on a single day in a single vehicle for those nine trips alone, not to mention the other 26. The provider took in more than $11 million in 2024-25.
* Of the 28,000 Medi-Cal providers considered at highest risk of fraud or abuse, the report said, the Department had not begun investigations into 26,000.
Find the report here
* * *
### California sues to stop National Archives closure that tribes say came without warning
The state of California filed a federal lawsuit against the National Archives and Records Administration on Oct. 14 seeking to keep open a facility whose closure was abruptly announced with no tribal, state or local consultation.
In late September, the records administration announced the closing of two locations, the San Francisco and Chicago National Archives. Tribal governments depend on the National Archives for records relating to the Bureau of Indian Affairs including enrollment records, land records and deeds, federal boarding school records and more.
California’s lawsuit asks the court to force the archives to halt the San Francisco facility closure.
It was filed the same day as...
* * *
## National news
* * *
### Trump administration appeals judge's order blocking White House ban of 3 news outlets
WASHINGTON — A federal judge late Tuesday extended a block on a Trump administration ban of press passes for three news organizations, which will allow them to continue to enter the White House grounds while a legal challenge to the ban, including a Wednesday appeal filed by the administration, plays out.
U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly in a 26-page order rejected Department of Justice arguments that the revocation of passes for CNN, Politico and MS NOW was based on the administration’s concern over reporting that endangered national security.
“First, there is no evidence in the record that President (Donald) Trump made the decision to revoke Plaintiffs’ hard passes on national security grounds from the get-go, nor at any time has he directly stated that national security was the reason for his decision. When he announced the ban with his post on September 18, he did not mention national security,” Kelly wrote.
Kelly also said the news organizations were likely to...
* * *
## Other sources
Members of Congress report mold, ‘filthy’ kitchenware during unannounced Adelanto ICE facility visitSeven Democratic members of Congress made a surprise visit on Friday, Oct. 16.San Bernardino SunBeau Yarbrough and Andrea KlickSan Bernardino Councilmember Treasure Ortiz sentenced to 30 days in jail and fined $500 for illegally recording police chiefOrtiz is appealing her conviction.San Bernardino SunIsrael J. Carreón Jr.
* * *
## Today in history: Rehnquist's court packing speech
October 18 is a day for American expansion. The United States took possession of Alaska on this date in 1867 for the equivalent of $132 million in today's money; and Spain evacuated Puerto Rico, leaving it under American control, on this date in 1898.
It's also the less-recognized anniversary of Supreme Court Justice William Rehnquist's court packing speech.
"A president who sets out to pack the court seeks to appoint to the court people who are sympathetic to his political or philosophical principle. There is no reason in the world why a president should not do this," Rehnquist told the University of Minnesota Law School on Oct. 18, 1984.
Despite a president's efforts, they aren't successful, he continued. The institution of the Supreme Court was pressuring justices to behave independently.
"(The new justice) identifies more and more strongly with the new institution of which he has become a member, and he learns how much store is set by his behaving independently of his colleague," he said.
Rehnquist, a Nixon appointee, was defending himself against accusations from his colleagues.
A month earlier, Justice Thurgood Marshall told judges on the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that the court's conservative majority had backtracked on precedent. They would acknowledge rights were violated, then decide not to issue a remedy, he said, according to United Press International.
"Decisions that (do not offer a remedy) will erode the faith in the law of those who rely on the law's protections," Marshall said. "Where no remedy is offered, or where the only ones offered can accomplish little, those who need the protection will have reason to turn away from the legal system."
At a private event that same month, Justice Harry Blackmun said the Supreme Court is "moving to the right," going "where it wants to go . . . by hook or by crook," according to the Washington Post.
Two months prior to Rehnquist's speech, Justice John Paul Stevens accused the majority of overreaching its authority in a speech to the Northwestern University Law School. He complained about five specific cases, mostly dealing with civil and defendants' rights, saying the majority had ignored principles taught in law school by inserting arguments not brought by the litigants.
"The court went out of its way to announce that the statute did not forbid sex discrimination throughout the assisted institution even though neither party had argued that it did," Stevens said regarding one case, according to the Washington Post.
The full audio of Rehnquist's speech is available here.
### Book recommendation
This week's book recommendation is The Burger Court and the Rise of the Judicial Right by By Michael J. Graetz and Linda Greenhouse.
_When Richard Nixon campaigned for the presidency in 1968 he promised to change the Supreme Court. With four appointments to the court, including Warren E. Burger as the chief justice, he did just that. In 1969, the Burger Court succeeded the famously liberal Warren Court, which had significantly expanded civil liberties and was despised by conservatives across the country.
The Burger Court is often described as a “transitional” court between the Warren Court and the Rehnquist and Roberts Courts, a court where little of importance happened. But as this “landmark new book” (The Christian Science Monitor) shows, the Burger Court veered well to the right in such areas as criminal law, race, and corporate power. Authors Graetz and Greenhouse excavate the roots of the most significant Burger Court decisions and in “elegant, illuminating arguments” (The Washington Post) show how their legacy affects us today._
$36 from Bookshop.org