Newsom moves to commute sentences of Kevin Cooper, Esperanza Fire arsonist, Palm Springs cop killer, Redlands abductors, 122 other regional sentences
Gov. Gavin Newsom announced he would reduce every death sentence in California to life without parole today. Of the 548 people on death row, 87 were charged by the Riverside County District Attorney's Office, and 40 were charged by the San Bernardino District Attorney's Office.
"I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes each of us," he wrote in an open letter.
Riverside District Attorney Michael Hestrin wrote that the decision disregards the victims, their families and the prosecutors who fought for the death sentences.
"The people of California deserve leaders who put politics and personal ambition aside and pursue truth, accountability, and justice with courage, integrity, and transparency. Instead, they have been presented with a decision that demonstrates a profound disregard for the victims, their families, and the prosecutors who dedicated themselves to seeking justice on their behalf," Hestrin wrote.
San Bernardino District Attorney Jason Anderson said the commutations were done without consulting victims or prosecutors.
"What the Governor seeks to do today is not courageous. It is arrogant and political showmanship. Governor Newsom substitutes his own aspirations in place of independently elected District Attorneys, hundreds of experienced prosecutors and judges, thousands of jurors, millions of voters, and most importantly, crime victims who have been consistently misled and denied justice by him and the California Legislature," Anderson wrote.
Only sentences in which the defendant was found guilty of a single felony can be unilaterally reduced by Newsom's pardon power. The California Constitution requires the governor's pardoning and commuting power to be checked by review of the Supreme Court for cases where the defendant was twice convicted of a felony. Seventy percent of the death sentences brought by Riverside and San Bernardino prosecutors resulted in more than one felony conviction, and will be reviewed by the California Supreme Court.
## The cases
### Kevin Cooper
The list of 127 people charged by Inland Empire prosecutors extends as far back as Kevin Cooper's 1985 sentence. Cooper was convicted of killing four people in Chino Hills, in what was known as the Chino Hills Massacre. The victims included 11-year-old Christopher Hughes, the couple Douglas and Peggy Ryen, and the Ryens' 10-year-old daughter, Jessica. A fifth victim, an 8-year-old, survived.
Anderson said Newsom had not contacted any victims or survivors when he decided to reduce Cooper's sentence to life without parole.
"The Governor is attempting to appear courageous with this decision. He is not courageous. His commutations are solely based upon power and political aspirations. Courage would require speaking with crime victims and the surviving family members of the people murdered by these death row inmates. The Governor has not called Josh Ryen or Mary Ann Hughes to ask them their opinion on a potential commutation for Kevin Cooper. Cooper, who slaughtered Josh’s entire family including Josh’s friend and Mary’s son, Chris Hughes, then left Josh for dead. Josh has lived with the impact of that horrific night his entire life. Josh has never received a call from Gavin Newsom," Anderson wrote.
Anderson and Newsom had previously sparred over Cooper's case.
Cooper maintained his innocence, and Newsom opened a fresh investigation into the case in 2023. The investigators concluded that Cooper was guilty of the murders. In 2023, Riverside District Attorney Jason Anderson refuted the governor's efforts in an open letter to Newsom.
"You have to wake up. Our Office will fight like hell. The victims’ family members will not be silenced. I am furious that my daughter and son could grow up in a California that is less safe than the one they were born into if you reduce Kevin Cooper’s death sentence or release him from custody while ignoring every court’s prior decision of guilt in this case," Anderson wrote.
### Esperanza fire, Palm Springs cop killer and Redlands abductors
The most recent sentence on the list is Ruben Corria Esquivel Jr.'s conviction in August. Esquivel was convicted of murder and arson on a property. He shot Vincent Aispuro in the Coachella Valley in 2020, after being told by Aispuro to leave his house, according to prosecutor statements reported by City News Group.
Also to be commuted are Raymond Lee Oyler, a serial arsonist responsible for the 2006 Esperanza Fire that killed five firefighters; Paul and Cathy Sarinana, who killed their 11-year-old nephew on Christmas Day in 2005 and John Hernandez Felix, who fatally shot Palm Springs officers Jose Gilbert "Gil" Vega and Lesley Zerebny in 2016. Michelle Paradise, who is projected to win the Riverside judicial election this week, prosecuted the Felix case.
The list also includes Cynthia Lynn Coffman and James Gregory Marlow, a couple convicted of abducting and killing four women in 1986; including Corinna Novis of Redlands.
The governor will also commute the sentences of Emrys Justin John, Kesaun Sykes and Tyrone Miller, three of the four American Marines convicted of the murder of United States Marine Corps Sergeant Jan Paweł Pietrzak and his wife, Quiana Jenkins-Pietrzak, in 2008.
Of these convicts, Cathy Lynn Sarinana, John, Sykes and Miller will not have their case reviewed by the California Supreme Court. The others will be reviewed because they have multiple felonies.
## Newsom's letter
Newsom wrote that the death penalty is against the state's morals.
"The people sentenced to death in California caused indescribable suffering to victims, their families, communities, and our state as a whole. The harm they inflicted persists across generations. Many Californians feel that those who commit brutal crimes deserve to die. But as Governor, I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them. I do, however, pray that this action will finally separate the memories of the victims of these crimes from the fate of those who harmed them. We can now let these offenders die in obscurity while we forever remember and honor their victims," Newsom wrote.
"This decision is among the most difficult of my career, not because I doubt its necessity for our state but because I know its announcement may surface excruciating memories for victims' families. I deeply respect the views of those who will strongly disagree with my decision, including some families of victims who have suffered the worst possible loss. I hold this painful truth along with the belief that this is a righteous action. Today I am acting on my long and deeply held conviction that individually and collectively we are stronger as a society when we reject state-sanctioned killing," he wrote.
"California voters have voted to keep the death penalty on the books, and I respect that. I recognize the limits of this clemency action, which does not repeal the death penalty and is limited to commuting California's current death sentences. The power to repeal the death penalty rests with the Legislature and voters. The discretion to seek, impose, and uphold death sentences in individual cases remains, as ever, in the hands of prosecutors, juries, and courts. But the constitution also gave every governor clemency authority, and that power exists for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice. For me, this is that moment," he wrote.
The full letter can be viewed here:
Newsom-open-letter-death-penaltyNewsom-open-letter-death-penalty.pdf193 KBdownload-circle
## DA Hestrin's response
Hestrin said the governor's sweeping decision ignored the victims of each case and the prosecutors who sought the death penalty.
_Today, the Governor of California commuted the sentences of every individual on California’s Death Row. He did so without notifying the District Attorneys whose offices prosecuted these cases and secured the convictions and sentences. Alarmingly, he did so without individualized input from each family of the victims whose lives were taken by these convicted murderers._
_Rather than undertake a careful, case-specific review of the evidence, legal proceedings, and circumstances of each case, the Governor once again chose to inject politics into California’s criminal justice system. This sweeping action, taken without meaningful consultation with prosecutors or victims’ families, raises serious questions about whose interests the Governor is truly representing._
_The people of California deserve leaders who put politics and personal ambition aside and pursue truth, accountability, and justice with courage, integrity, and transparency. Instead, they have been presented with a decision that demonstrates a profound disregard for the victims, their families, and the prosecutors who dedicated themselves to seeking justice on their behalf._
_The Governor has a responsibility to serve all Californians, including those whose lives have been forever changed by violent crime. Today’s action falls far short of that responsibility. The people of California deserve better._
## DA Anderson's response
_Today, Governor Newsom announced his desire to grant blanket commutations for every death row inmate in California. It is the wrong decision._
_The Governor is attempting to appear courageous with this decision. He is not courageous. His commutations are solely based upon power and political aspirations. Courage would require speaking with crime victims and the surviving family members of the people murdered by these death row inmates. The Governor has not called Josh Ryen or Mary Ann Hughes to ask them their opinion on a potential commutation for Kevin Cooper. Cooper, who slaughtered Josh’s entire family including Josh’s friend and Mary’s son, Chris Hughes, then left Josh for dead. Josh has lived with the impact of that horrific night his entire life. Josh has never received a call from Gavin Newsom._
_Courage would require the Governor to follow Marsy’s Law, California’s constitutional rights belonging to victims of crime. He has not. I am not aware of any victims’ family members receiving notice of these commutations from the Governor. Courage would also require the Governor to respect democracy and the will of the people by acknowledging that the people of California have consistently and repeatedly voted in favor of the death penalty in California. The Governor is concerned with politics, not people. The Governor ignores victims and their families constitutional rights with this decision. He has placed the lives and interests of convicted murderers above victims and their families._
_Finally, courage would demand that the Governor respect the greatest example of democracy that exists, the jury system. These death sentences that the Governor is attempting to commute were all imposed by twelve members of the community who each had to independently determine that these condemned inmates were guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and determine that the crimes were so heinous that death was the only appropriate sentence. Jurors understand that not everyone should be treated the same for every homicide, because there are murders so horrific that no other verdict could be just. Gavin Newsom does not understand this, and has never attempted to understand this._
_What the Governor seeks to do today is not courageous. It is arrogant and political showmanship. Governor Newsom substitutes his own aspirations in place of independently elected District Attorneys, hundreds of experienced prosecutors and judges, thousands of jurors, millions of voters, and most importantly, crime victims who have been consistently misled and denied justice by him and the California Legislature._
## The history of capital punishment
Executions were authorized by counties in 1851, according to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. In 1872, the law was amended to require executions be done in a private place, with the presence of the county sheriff, a physician, the district attorney, at least 12 reputable citizens and the optional invitation of the convict's minister, relatives and friends. The first state execution was held in 1893, at San Quentin State Prison. In 1937, the legislature replaced hanging as the method of capital punishment with legal gas. From 1938 until 1967, 194 people were executed by gas at San Quentin.
In 1972, the California Supreme Court outlawed the death penalty in the case People v. Anderson. The court found that a death sentence was a cruel and unusual punishment, in violation of California's Constitution.
"We have concluded that capital punishment is impermissibly cruel. It degrades and dehumanizes all who participate in its processes. It is unnecessary to any legitimate goal of the state and is incompatible with the dignity of man and the judicial process," the court said.
California voters reinstated the death penalty by proposition, 5.4 million to 2.6 million voters, the same year. The most recent execution was carried out in 2006. In 2012, Californians voted to keep the death penalty: 6 million votes against the death penalty and 6.5 million votes against. The vote was repeated in 2016, with the same result: 6.3 against the death penalty to 7.2 million for it. Newsom said he would pause carrying out death sentences in 2019.
## Judicial review
Cases that involve more than one felony have to be reviewed by the California Supreme Court before they are commuted to life without parole. Of the 127 convicts charged by the Riverside or San Bernardino District Attorney, 89 of the convicts were convicted of more than one felony. Of the 548 death convicts statewide, 382 people were convicted of more than one felony.
"While I am confident this act of categorical clemency is consistent with California law, I acknowledge that my decision to exercise my constitutional clemency authority requires the Justices to participate in a weighty decision they did not choose to take up and with which they may personally disagree. I profoundly appreciate the integrity and expertise the Court brings to the task of clemency review," Newsom wrote.
## Future cases
The decision will not affect future sentences. Incoming Governor Xavier Becerra has said he will continue Newsom's pause on executions.
The California legislature recently passed the Racial Justice Act (RJA), allowing for a new defense against charges. The RJA prohibits charging people of one race more than another for similarly situated crimes.
Last week, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) argued the filing of death charges against a Latina and Black defendant was at least partly based on the defendant's race. Prosecutors allege the defendant committed a pre-planned triple homicide of a family.
Prosecutor William Murray said it was one of the worst cases he had seen, and that the ACLU picked a bad case to test the defense. Riverside Superior Judge Charles Koosed has not yet made his ruling. Read the arguments presented at the hearing below:
ACLU asks Riv. death trial to be reduced to life with Racial Justice Act defense"This case is a one of one. I'm not saying it's hard to bring a Racial Justice Act violation. I'm not saying it's impossible. It's happened in Riverside County. I'm saying the defense team and the ACLU chose a really hard case to compare to," prosecutor William Murray said.Inland Empire Law WeeklyAidan McGloin
## List of convicts to be commuted by Newsom