ChatGPT's New Business Profiles, Google's Silent Review Bans & the War on Scrapers | EP 283
Clicking the video loads it from YouTube, which sends data to Google under its privacy policy. Prefer not to? Watch on YouTube.
🎧 Load podcast player
The player is hosted by Buzzsprout. Loading it sends data such as your IP address to Buzzsprout under its privacy policy. Or listen on Buzzsprout.
Greg Sterling and Mike Blumenthal go hosts-only for a four-part episode. Mike screen-shares a live tour of OpenAI's Businesses in ChatGPT dashboard next to Google and Apple insights for the same jeweler. After that he walks through a two-location HVAC client that Google quietly blocked from getting reviews. The last two segments cover Google's escalating campaign against scrapers and the Ask Maps holiday features almost nobody has heard of.
The platforms are fighting over first-party business data. OpenAI is asking businesses to hand it over, and Google is walling its own results off from everyone else, so local businesses and the tools that serve them end up with thinner analytics, opaque penalties and a measurement stack that has to move toward outcomes.
## Takeaways
* **ChatGPT's business profile is easy to claim and hard to scale.** OpenAI launched Businesses in ChatGPT on November 10. A business verifies by phone, text or a DNS TXT record and then passes a Persona identity check to get the blue check. Mike calls a single location trivial, but the friction grows with every location; a 50-location brand is "very difficult." He also flags the government ID and face scan as a poor fit for anyone doing political work. _(01:28–04:44)_
* **The analytics are a thin funnel with 7- and 28-day windows.** For Barbara Oliver Jewelry in Buffalo, ChatGPT reported 46 mentions, five profile views and six website visits over 28 days. Discovery topics are broad buckets like "local service providers," not prompts or keywords, so Mike finds nothing actionable. _(04:44–06:55)_ [1]
* **Apple out-delivers ChatGPT for the same business.** Over a comparable month, Apple Business showed 65 taps from local search, about ten times ChatGPT's figure. It also broke out brand and category searches, a map of where searchers were, and nine phone calls. Mike's estimate puts Apple at roughly a quarter of Google's local volume, which makes ChatGPT's current referral value small. _(07:55–10:05)_
* **The real story may be that Apple is a local player.** ChatGPT's limited numbers end up showing how much local activity Apple already captures. Greg expects Apple's share to grow as Siri gets better at flexible local queries and Apple moves toward full-funnel search in a single interface. _(10:57–11:44)_
* **Claim it anyway, especially single-location businesses.** OpenAI promises no ranking boost, but the check mark may lend credibility. The Business Agent chat, drawn from the business's own site and inputs, could convert questions like "is this in stock?" Greg sees the Shopify catalog import as the strongest use case, because product search in ChatGPT already outpaces local. _(12:08–13:21, 17:11–17:30)_
* **Agentic chat is a workflow problem before it is a feature.** Google is rolling out its own AI agent in Business Profile messaging that hands customers off when it can't answer. Mike's worry is a business juggling handoffs from Google, ChatGPT and others with no central inbox. Google also has a history of killing communication products businesses built around. _(13:21–14:43)_
* **The dashboard is a sales funnel and a data pipeline.** Greg reads the "GSC Lite" dashboard as an upsell into ChatGPT ads and business subscriptions. He also sees a direct feed of business data as a hedge against Google's anti-scraping moves. Mike adds that the local battlefield "has a lot of bodies from vendors," and adoption will need agencies as a channel, since only a minority of businesses actively manage even their Google profiles. _(15:31–17:11)_
* **Google review bans switch on automatically and need a human to lift them.** A two-location HVAC client (separate cities, two hours apart) lost the ability to get reviews at one location from late September. Google never told them. Support confirmed the restriction only when asked, and removed it only after a second request and an internal escalation. It ended roughly five weeks after it began. _(18:25–19:35, 21:59)_
* **A ten-day spike plus repeat reviewers plus employee names lined up with the ban.** With the unbanned location as a control, Mike tested which review-velocity window matched the ban. A spike against the previous ten days fit best, but that spike was no bigger than earlier seasonal ones. What changed was that customers reviewing both locations and reviews naming employees rose in the same window. Mike stresses this is correlation, not proof. _(20:14–21:44)_
* **The fix: back off asking, link to the brand, monitor volume.** Mike's client paused review requests during the ban and sent the brand URL instead of the review link. Mike's advice for seasonal home-service businesses: watch for a sudden drop in review volume, confirm with Google, and lift the ban after volume eases. Stop prompting customers to name employees, which Greg calls a proxy for incentivized reviews. _(21:44–21:59, 25:26–27:25)_
* **Google bans reviews for other reasons too.** Mike lists geofenced bans around the overturning of _Dobbs_ , wartime Israel, the Olympics and the World Cup, plus bans on businesses being spammed by competitors. Greg, drawing on expert witness work in a review fraud case, says review spikes at odd times of year are likely the first signal that draws Google's attention. _(17:36–18:25, 22:28, 24:52–25:26)_
* **Google's anti-scraping escalation, step by step.** It started with JavaScript in January 2025 and the removal of the num=100 parameter in September 2025. Then came the DMCA suit against SerpApi in December 2025, dismissed twice. After that: google.com/goto redirects from July and poisoned results served to bots. The latest is a sign-in prompt after a single search. _(29:55–32:24)_ [2]
* **A login wall turns "no scraping" into an enforceable contract.** Mike's point: copyright and hacking theories failed, but a sign-in gate binds the user to Google's terms, which forbid scraping. Greg calls it hypocritical, since Google built local search on the principle that facts can't be copyrighted, starting with listings keyed in from phone books. Both think it will hit small SaaS tools, ranking grids and agencies hardest, and land as a shot across the bow of ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude. _(32:24–36:36)_ [3]
* **Rank tracking's days as a client metric are numbered.** Mike says agencies that still report rankings to end clients should stop. He would move to conversion metrics such as calls, door traffic and tracked outcomes, and accept that the middle of the funnel will get murkier. Greg expects a login wall to be a non-starter in Europe, and Mike thinks it would inflame Google's US antitrust cases. _(36:52–38:48)_
* **Ask Maps is Google's best AI product and nobody knows it exists.** Google's November 16 post added itineraries, route tips, appointment finding and saved-list search. Greg uses Ask Maps more than any Google product outside Gmail and Docs. Mike polled about 16 family members and friends, many of them heavy Google Maps users in their thirties, and not one knew the feature. He wants it to be the default Maps search. _(38:48–41:49)_
* **Google markets on TikTok, but not Ask Maps.** Greg sees Google TikTok ads aimed at young women about holiday shopping and asks why Ask Maps, with real utility and a public souring on AI, isn't the campaign. Mike's answer is culture: Google launches early and buggy, waits for viral uptake, and takes products down if they don't catch on. He calls it a Darwinian approach that businesses and consumers hate. _(42:24–44:22)_
### Related Reading
* OpenAI lets businesses claim ChatGPT profiles and launch their own agents (The Next Web) — what Businesses in ChatGPT and Business Hub include.
* How to claim your business in ChatGPT (B12) — the claim steps, verification methods and Persona identity check.
* Google Business Profiles AI-Powered Messaging Expands (Search Engine Roundtable) — the GBP AI agent that answers routine questions and hands off the rest.
* ChatGPT gains access to Yelp reviews, ratings, and photos (Search Engine Land) — the Yelp licensing deal Mike cites.
* Google loses key DMCA claims against SerpApi (Search Engine Land) — the July 20 ruling, and SerpApi on the second dismissal.
* Confirmed: Google Search Rolling Out google.com/goto Tracking Parameters (Search Engine Roundtable) — the redirect change that broke many rank trackers.
* Analysis: Google Is Poisoning Search Results For Rank Trackers (Search Engine Journal) — Nozzle's data on swapped results served to bots.
* Google Tests Sign In Protections After First Search To Block Scrapers (Search Engine Roundtable) — the Brodie Clark sighting and Google's response.
* New Ask Maps features to help with holiday travel and prep (Google) — the post Greg discusses.
* Customers still use Google, but small businesses don't think it's important (BrightLocal) — the GBP adoption data behind Greg's "minority actively manage" point, from last week's Near Memo with Myles Anderson.
## Practitioner Notes
* **Add review-volume monitoring to every home-services and PI account.** Mike's case shows a ban can run for weeks with no notice. Include a weekly review-count check per location in GBP audits; a sudden flat line is the trigger to open a support case.
* **Strip employee-name prompts from review-request templates.** Technician-specific links and "mention who helped you" asks create the exact proxy Mike found in the ban window. For multi-location clients, route repeat customers to the location that actually served them.
* **Claim ChatGPT profiles for single-location clients now; hold multi-location rollouts.** The Business Hub can't handle many locations yet. Use the DNS TXT route where you control hosting, and log the 28-day mentions/visits baseline for comparison against GBP and Apple Business.
* **Rebuild client reporting around calls and conversions.** With /goto redirects, poisoned SERPs and a possible login wall, grid and rank data is getting less reliable. Call tracking and GBP actions are already the core of our PI and GBP audit work and should lead client reports.
### Pick your starting point:
00:00 Intro
01:28 OpenAI launches Businesses in ChatGPT
02:31 Claiming a profile: easy for one, hard for fifty
04:44 ChatGPT's analytics for a real business
06:55 The same business on Google and Apple
10:57 Apple is a bigger local player than you think
12:08 Should you claim your ChatGPT profile?
13:22 Google's AI chat agent and the workflow problem
17:30 Google's silent review bans
18:25 Case study: two HVAC locations, one ban
20:14 What lined up with the ban
25:57 How to avoid and lift a review ban
28:37 Google's war on scrapers
32:24 A login wall as a contract
36:52 Rank tracking's days are numbered
38:48 Ask Maps: Google's best AI product
42:24 Why isn't Google marketing it?
### Full Transcript --> On-Line
* * *
Interested in sponsoring this podcast or our newsletters please reach out to mblumenthal@nearmedia.co
E-mail Mike