Graphics Development • Re: What sw to use for editing sprite sheets?
> > So what do you all use for editing sprites? How can the palette in a .png be preserved, so it'll work?
>
> I also had initial palette issues with GIMP that I do not completely understand. Started from scratch and tried to load the OTTD palette which I thought was correct but it did not work.
>
> However, when you start from an existing file with a correct palette and then simply use that as a template for everything else, it works - never any problems again.
>
> Also, I don't find GIMP that heavy - don't need to care about the functionality you don't need and slowly you will improve your skills with it. And it's free and for many platforms - I use it on Windows 11.
I don't mind using GIMP - if it works consistently. But it seems to fail randomly for me. I always start with file that is ok, then edit a sprite. Then I "Export" a png to a different filename, do a test compile and a test load in openttd. Edit another sprite or two, export, failure due to messed-up palette in the png. At that point, I see no other way than throw away the last edits and start over with a working file. Maybe I get another signal sprite done, maybe not. There are 64 little sprites for these signals, not much fun if I mostly have to start over.
So far, I have not been able to figure out why GIMP sometimes go wrong. It'd be easier if I knew what to avoid. But all I do is mark, copy, paste, merge the pixels in the paste layer into the image. And repeat this sequence a lot. Sometimes, also an undo or two. I will experiment some more, but simple edits to 64 sprites is not realistic, if I often have to re-do the same edit. I have patience for work, but no patience for "trying the same thing again and again, hoping it will work this time".
Statistics: Posted by Hafting — 18 Nov 2026 11:22
* * *