Shades of Things to Come..
[Google Images][BlogNotes: [i] an excerpt from an WFNTopaZ podcast series, 'Shades of Things to Come'. Our man Topaz is interviewing Dr. Quentin Dorward, distinguished Professor of Philosophy of History, about his latest book; [ii] some of these ideas are borrowed from the ScrabbleMeister...]Topaz: Thanks for taking time out of your busy book-signing tour to talk about this latest book of yours..The Cult of the Latest [PC] Cause..Quentin: Delighted..delighted.Always good to shed a little more light on the darkness [laughs]Topaz: So, why don't you tell the listeners how you got the idea for the book?Quentin: Well, Topaz,,,can I call you Topaz? you must have noticed that we are living in strait times in our history, not only past history but history in the 'present tense' if you will..Topaz: Strait times?Quentin: Strait times, Topaz. The nation's history--or perhaps I should say histories--are being challenged at every important cultural level. During a recent lecture to undergrads on campus, I suddenly channelled The Cult of the Lost Cause, an anthem from the old Confederate SouthTopaz: ..that was the deification of General Lee, if memory serves..Quentin: Correct, that and much much more. So let me review --briefly for you and your listeners--what some of these warning signs look like:1. First, certain flags which have flown in our cities and capitals fro decades are now considered offensive by some cultural groups. Indeed, in some cities, flags have been removed as a result of citizen pressure..2. Similarly, statues that weathered nicely through the ages in various cities are now suspect. You probably read about the removal of 4 such offensive statues in a city in the deep south...all removed at dead of night..3. Many schools who proudly sport historical figures [as names, mascots] are now being pressured to change their names. The recent case of JEB Stuart HS in Virginia is a case in point. There is a similar movement afoot to change street signs in several cities also..4. School history textbooks are also under scrutiny, mostly for the ways they either tell or don't tell the story of American exceptionalism. Interestingly, thoughtful versions of 'meta' stories--Frances Fitzgerald's America Revised--are suddenly and mysteriously out of print.Nothing, or so it seems, is off limits to these missionary rhapsodic revisionists.Topaz: Sounds to me like a crusade..Quentin: Exactly my point..The Cult of the Latest [PC] Cause writ large! There is definitely a movement afoot to alter, no..make that sanitize the Nation's narrative, and, as one of my reviewers wrote: 'this ill-informed movement want to eradicate the painful 'bits' of history and make it look like they never happened..'Topaz: So, what's to be done then?Quentin: In the book, I offer three courses of action:[a] regarding street and school names, we should take a page out of the Republic of Ireland's book, and make all names bilingual. Irish Gaelic might not be the best choice for the large print name [with the English underneath] but some language other than English will 'shrink' the importance of the actual name..[an expiration date, plus Latin genus would also be helpful..][b] regarding school history texts, all texts should disabuse themselves of text [historical narratives] with a good, old-fashioned purge, and simply offer a timeline of dates and events. For example:1862 Battle of Fredericksburg.. [no explanation, no opinion]...this, hopefully, will free students to become honest researchers of the topic [if they happen to be interested..Wikipedia pages only]..[c] A recent conference in Boulder, Co., solved, for this historian, the answer to this thorny question of Statues. On Pearl Street there is a generic statue to a generic soldier--could be a soldier in any war-- with the inscription In Memory of the Fallen. All current statues that some folks find offensive should be airlifted to a large park outside the city limits and placed strategically on the grounds by era. Something teachable should accompany the statue with the hope that folks actually learn the lessons of history..[or, alternately, Statue of the Unknown ______, fill in your own nationality]..Topaz: We're running out of time, Quentin. Thanks so much for taking the time out of your very busy schedule to share some of your book's most interesting and seminal ideas..Quentin: My pleasure. Now let me personally sign a copy for your collection...