StudyBuddies
PeerReviewers
SpecialCases
StudyBuddies
PeerReviewers
SpecialCases
Learn about #AGUPubs efforts to support women in publishing: https://buff.ly/4aXSAGv
#February11 #WomenInSTEM
Learn about #AGUPubs efforts to support women in publishing: https://buff.ly/4aXSAGv
#February11 #WomenInSTEM
files.constantcontact.com/ccd1b400301/... @tandfresearch.bsky.social
If you are interested in joining the AGU pool of reviewers, please fill out our interest form: buff.ly/ZezWxq4
#PRW2025 #AGUPubs #PeerReviewWeek
If you are interested in joining the AGU pool of reviewers, please fill out our interest form: buff.ly/ZezWxq4
#PRW2025 #AGUPubs #PeerReviewWeek
Thank you to all our #authors, #editors and #peerreviewers 🌟
Thank you to all our #authors, #editors and #peerreviewers 🌟
@lseimpactblog.bsky.social
@lseimpactblog.bsky.social
#futureofpublishing #scholarlypublishing #amediting
#futureofpublishing #scholarlypublishing #amediting
doi.org/10.24318/cop...
#PeerReview #PublicationEthics #FakePeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PhDchat #ECRchat #NewPI
doi.org/10.24318/cop...
#PeerReview #PublicationEthics #FakePeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PhDchat #ECRchat #NewPI
Fact: Publishers struggle w effective reviewers for books & journals .....
E: catherine.anderson@reviewercredits.com for a demo 👉 www.reviewercredits.com/publisher-si... ✅ 🎉
#peerreview #ResearchIntegrity #publishing
Fact: Publishers struggle w effective reviewers for books & journals .....
E: catherine.anderson@reviewercredits.com for a demo 👉 www.reviewercredits.com/publisher-si... ✅ 🎉
#peerreview #ResearchIntegrity #publishing
#PeerReviewWeek #GlobalPeerReview #AcademicSky #PeerReviewers
#PeerReviewWeek #GlobalPeerReview #AcademicSky #PeerReviewers
HOW COME YOUR JOURNAL IS NOT USING REVIEWER CREDITS?
#PeerReview #PublishingIntegrity #ResearchIntegrity
HOW COME YOUR JOURNAL IS NOT USING REVIEWER CREDITS?
#PeerReview #PublishingIntegrity #ResearchIntegrity
If the language becomes more certain than the evidence allows, point out exactly where the interpretation goes too far.
Save this for your next review.
#PeerReview #PeerReviewTips #AcademicSky #Edusky #PeerReviewers
If the language becomes more certain than the evidence allows, point out exactly where the interpretation goes too far.
Save this for your next review.
#PeerReview #PeerReviewTips #AcademicSky #Edusky #PeerReviewers
Crime Fiction Studies are on the hunt for colleagues interested in collaborating with the journal as #peerreviewers. If you would like to work with us, please get in touch via our email (crimefictionstudies@gmail.com) with your research areas & interests! #AcademicSky
Crime Fiction Studies are on the hunt for colleagues interested in collaborating with the journal as #peerreviewers. If you would like to work with us, please get in touch via our email (crimefictionstudies@gmail.com) with your research areas & interests! #AcademicSky
(does it show I've been uselessly looking at bios of many to figure out if they might be useful peerreviewers?)
(does it show I've been uselessly looking at bios of many to figure out if they might be useful peerreviewers?)
☑ Data availability
☑ Limitations
☑ Conflicts of interest
☑ Reporting guidelines
Vote, then tell us what you wish reviewers checked more consistently.
#AcademicX #PeerReviewers #ManuscriptReview #PeerReviewSkills #ReviewerOne
☑ Data availability
☑ Limitations
☑ Conflicts of interest
☑ Reporting guidelines
Vote, then tell us what you wish reviewers checked more consistently.
#AcademicX #PeerReviewers #ManuscriptReview #PeerReviewSkills #ReviewerOne
The reviewer’s job is not to demand perfect data. It is to check whether the uncertainty has been handled honestly.
What makes you most cautious when you see missing data in a manuscript?
#PeerReview #PeerReviewers #ReviewerTip #ReviewerSkills #AcademicSky #Edusky #AcademicChatter
The reviewer’s job is not to demand perfect data. It is to check whether the uncertainty has been handled honestly.
What makes you most cautious when you see missing data in a manuscript?
#PeerReview #PeerReviewers #ReviewerTip #ReviewerSkills #AcademicSky #Edusky #AcademicChatter
❓Clearer review criteria
❓Better manuscript matching
❓More realistic deadlines
❓Feedback after the decision
Which one would help you most, and why?
#PeerReview #ReviewerSupport #PeerReviewSkills #AcademicSkills
❓Clearer review criteria
❓Better manuscript matching
❓More realistic deadlines
❓Feedback after the decision
Which one would help you most, and why?
#PeerReview #ReviewerSupport #PeerReviewSkills #AcademicSkills
• Unsupported conclusion
• Unclear sampling
• Inconsistent terminology
• Missing references
What would you raise first in the report, and why?
Curious to see how Reviewers prioritize them.
#PeerReview #AcademicSky #PeerReviewers #Researchers
• Unsupported conclusion
• Unclear sampling
• Inconsistent terminology
• Missing references
What would you raise first in the report, and why?
Curious to see how Reviewers prioritize them.
#PeerReview #AcademicSky #PeerReviewers #Researchers